Holdfast: Nations At War

VS

Roblox

Holdfast: Nations At War is a historical multiplayer shooter with large-scale battles, released in 2020. It's a niche indie title with a dedicated but relatively small community, typically attracting a couple thousand daily players now, four years after launch. The game supports large matches but does not meet the scale of a persistent MMO world.

Roblox is a massively popular sandbox platform, released in 2006 but continually updated and widely adopted by younger audiences globally. It consistently reports tens of millions of monthly active users, with peak daily actives usually around 5–10% of monthly users. Recent filings and reports indicate Roblox has over 60 million daily active users, but this covers global user logins across many devices and experiences. Adjusting conservatively for reporting and engagement variance, daily actives typically exceed 50 million worldwide, but simultaneous users generally peak in the hundreds of thousands to low millions. As a platform with persistent worlds, it fits the broader MMO definition.