Head to head
New Club Penguin vs Nightmare
Side by side
Values shared by both games are highlighted.
Status
Released
Daily players
Estimated players
Available on
- Browser
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
Player activity
Smoothed estimated players over time.
New Club Penguin
| Month | Estimated players | Change |
|---|---|---|
| September 2026 | ~42.7k | Down 1.9% |
| August 2026 | ~43.6k | Down 0.5% |
| July 2026 | ~43.8k | — |
Nightmare
| Month | Estimated players | Change |
|---|---|---|
| September 2026 | ~207 | Down 0.5% |
| August 2026 | ~208 | Up 0.5% |
| July 2026 | ~207 | — |
Community breakdown
Steam, Discord, Reddit, Twitch, and YouTube activity for both games, side by side.
Discord members
- New Club Penguin
- 184.5kUp 0.1%
- Nightmare
- 656Down 0.2%
New Club Penguin currently has about 281× as many Discord members as Nightmare — 184,472 vs 656.
YouTube subscribers
- New Club Penguin
- 5.4k
- Nightmare
- 75
New Club Penguin currently has about 72× as many YouTube subscribers as Nightmare — 5,380 vs 75.
Steam concurrent players
- New Club Penguin
- —
- Nightmare
- 0Down 100%
Nightmare currently has 0 peak concurrent Steam players; no comparable data is tracked for New Club Penguin.
How these estimates are made
New Club Penguin
New Club Penguin is estimated to have 51 – 24k players a day. Around 18k – 2m accounts have played it in total. No Steam data is published for this game, so the range is modelled from the size of its Discord, Reddit, Twitch, YouTube and app-store communities. It is a rough band rather than a measurement.
Nightmare
Nightmare is estimated to have 3 – 9 players a day. Around 8k – 21k accounts have played it in total. The range is anchored on Steam’s official concurrent-player and review counts, then converted to daily actives and accounts — so it covers the Steam player base and will under-count a game played mostly through its own launcher or on console.