Head to head

4Story Online vs Puzzle Pirates

4Story Online

Live

15 – 7k daily

Puzzle Pirates

Live

950 – 3k daily

Side by side

Values shared by both games are highlighted.

Status

ACTIVE

Released

December 2008 · 18 years ago

December 2003 · 23 years ago

Daily players

15 – 7k

950 – 3k

Estimated players

537.2%

2.4k2.5%

Available on

Windows

Windows
macOS
Linux

Platforms

Windows

Perspectives

Third Person

Player activity

Smoothed estimated players over time.

4Story OnlinePuzzle Pirates

4Story Online

Average monthly estimated players
Month	Estimated players	Change
November 2026	~53	Down 3.6%
October 2026	~55	Up 3.8%
September 2026	~53	Up 1.9%
August 2026	~52	Up 11%
July 2026	~47	—

Puzzle Pirates

Average monthly estimated players
Month	Estimated players	Change
November 2026	~2.3k	Up 5.3%
October 2026	~2.2k	Up 4.2%
September 2026	~2.1k	Up 3.0%
August 2026	~2k	Up 1.7%
July 2026	~2k	—

Community breakdown

Steam, Discord, Reddit, Twitch, and YouTube activity for both games, side by side.

Reddit members

4Story Online: 480Up 5.3%
Puzzle Pirates: 3.8kUp 4.1%

Puzzle Pirates currently has about 8× as many subreddit members as 4Story Online — 3,840 vs 480.

Twitch viewers

4Story Online: 23Down 30%
Puzzle Pirates: 7Up 133%

4Story Online currently has about 3.3× as many live Twitch viewers as Puzzle Pirates — 23 vs 7.

Steam concurrent players

4Story Online: —
Puzzle Pirates: 264Down 4.0%

Puzzle Pirates currently has 264 peak concurrent Steam players; no comparable data is tracked for 4Story Online.

Discord members

4Story Online: —
Puzzle Pirates: 5.1kUp 6.9%

Puzzle Pirates currently has 5,088 Discord members; no comparable data is tracked for 4Story Online.

How these estimates are made

4Story Online

4Story Online is estimated to have 15 – 7k players a day. Around 8k – 790k accounts have played it in total. No Steam data is published for this game, so the range is modelled from the size of its Discord, Reddit, Twitch, YouTube and app-store communities. It is a rough band rather than a measurement.

Puzzle Pirates

Puzzle Pirates is estimated to have 950 – 3k players a day. Around 57k – 150k accounts have played it in total. The range is anchored on Steam’s official concurrent-player and review counts, then converted to daily actives and accounts — so it covers the Steam player base and will under-count a game played mostly through its own launcher or on console.